Patrick J Battuello

Archive for the ‘Chimpanzees’ Category

More Like Us…

In Chimpanzees, Intelligence/Emotions, Philosophy on July 26, 2011 at 1:08 pm

Rene Descartes, 17th Century philosopher, is a notorious figure in animal rights history. In brief, he asserted that animals, being mindless, could not truly experience pain and suffering (as we understand the words). In practice, this theory informed our treatment of animals (especially in the laboratory) for centuries. The animals’ plight improved only slightly through Immanuel Kant’s influence (though irrational animals are means and not ends, we should still treat them well in order to cultivate good behavior towards each other). It wasn’t until 1966′s Animal Welfare Act that our government acknowledged animal pain; that is, they are not just robots and need some protection (weak as it is) from scalpels and electric currents. But ever-changing knowledge (in this case, of animal intelligence) demands a reconsideration of the human-animal relationship.

Science (ethological and cognitive studies), irrepressible by nature, will continue to raze barriers (between us and them) by gleaning new insights into the animal mind. Capacities and depth heretofore thought exclusive to homo sapiens are being unearthed across the species spectrum. And only the willfully ignorant, entrenched in the dark past, choose to ignore.

Two recent studies of the chimpanzee offer prime examples of this movable bar. First, researchers from St. Andrews have identified 66 different communicative gestures for wild chimps, doubling the previous findings. In addition, they also believe that these communications are species-wide (and not simply learned customs within a group). In the second study (Kyoto University), researchers discovered that chimpanzees have a definitive sense of self (beyond the mirror test). Using a computer game, the scientists tested the chimps’ ability to determine which of two cursors they could control, and then identifying them later. They could, and did. The study concludes that “chimpanzees and humans share fundamental cognitive processes underlying the sense of being an independent agent.”

The chimpanzee, as man’s first cousin, is an easy object for sympathy. We care about their pain because the similarities are uncomfortable. But in the words of the philosopher Jeremy Bentham, “What is it that should trace the insuperable line?” Is it underestimated intelligence (pigs), self-awareness (elephants, dolphins), intricate social orders and family relationships (chickens, turkeys), undeniable mother-child bonds (goats), or distinct personalities with broad emotional range (our pets)? No, none of these. Bentham simply asked, “Can they suffer?” In suffering, all sentient animals are our cousins. And, as cousins, they deserve a new place in our world. Not as tools, but rather as ends unto themselves.

The Cle Elum Seven

In Chimpanzees, Experimentation on June 23, 2011 at 12:47 pm

They were once just numbered research material sentenced to a hellish existence inside tiny cages at nondescript, windowless laboratories. Their lives meant nothing beyond their value (to human beings) as test subjects. Given our genetic connection with chimpanzees, is it that difficult to imagine (empathize with) their sadness? Their helplessness? A sadness and helplessness, by the way, measured in decades. A sadness and helplessness sometimes descending into madness. Now, though, we can call them a family:

Annie

Burrito

Foxie

Jamie

Jody

Missy

Negra

They live among friends at Chimpanzee Sanctuary Northwest (CSNW) near Seattle. CSNW was founded by Keith LaChappelle (with his $200,000 life’s savings) in 2003 after he read an article about research chimps. Keith told Seattle Met Magazine, “It talked about how a lot of chimpanzees aren’t actively being used for research, but they’re still languishing in these five-by-five lab cages because there’s nowhere for them to go.” While visiting other sanctuaries (at one, he looked into the eyes of a chimp who had endured 50 biopsies and knew what must be done), LaChappelle met Sarah Baeckler (see Chimps on (and off) Stage), and they decided to join forces (along with Diana Goodrich and J.P. Mulcahy). It so happened that seven chimpanzees were rotting away in a basement pen at Buckshire in Pennsylvania (a business that leased animals for laboratory testing). LaChappelle says, (Seattle Times, 8/25/08) “The…idea of these individuals stuck in a cage, with nowhere to go, and to keep them in those cages for decades… I just couldn’t imagine that. Chimps have self-awareness and understand where they’re at.”

There are at least 1,000 chimpanzees withering in American laboratories (and roughly 600 in 10 American/Canadian sanctuaries). There is a pending bill in Congress (the Great Ape Protection Act) that would prohibit invasive procedures on all great apes and provide for the permanent retirement of those who are federally-owned (the estimated 500 who belong to us). Public sentiment is trending towards a quasi-legal recognition of our closest cousins.

The evil that has been visited upon laboratory chimps is unconscionable. The painful procedures, will-breaking confinement, psychological abuse, and emotional trauma (which often includes severing the mother-child bond) cannot be defended, no matter the benefits gained.

Primatologist Debra Durham is studying the effects of trauma on chimpanzees who have been imprisoned for most of their lives. She writes: “The United States is the only nation in the world to continue using chimpanzees in large-scale invasive experiments. Even in America, many chimpanzees in laboratories are essentially warehoused, no longer used in active protocols because they haven’t proved useful as models for human diseases, but still kept in laboratory cages.” One such chimp was Jeannie. Her story is profoundly sad.

These wonderful, beautiful beings, once rescued, should be sterilized (which appears to be sanctuary norm). The bastardization of their species should end with this generation. For now, the good people at CSNW deserve our admiration, gratitude, and respect. Though hoping to provide a measure of happiness after the storm, LaChappelle cautions, “It’s not retirement. They’re really still captive chimpanzees. It’s dignity. We’re giving them dignity.” Please encourage your congressperson to support HR1326. Please, also, consider sponsoring a chimp at CSNW (or any other sanctuary). It’s the least we can do.

Chimps on (and off) Stage

In Chimpanzees on June 23, 2011 at 1:46 am

“[The young chimps] were being kicked in the face and punched in the head and subject to all kinds of physical abuse to keep them paying attention and in line with the trainer.” (Dr. Sarah Baeckler on what she witnessed at Amazing Animal Actors)

Chimpanzees are our closest living relatives, sharing 98% of our DNA. They are self-aware and extraordinarily intelligent (even cunning and deceptive). They have a keen memory and are, remarkably, altruistic (a quality previously thought exclusive to humans). Chimps are also sensitive, experiencing a full range of emotions: they know comfort and fear, love and loss, joy and sorrow, pleasure and pain. And yes, they can suffer. For chimpanzees born and raised for entertainment, that suffering has several phases, each worse than the previous.

Young captive chimps are torn from their mothers between one and two (in the wild, they are practically attached to their moms for seven years). Jane Goodall, primatologist and the world’s foremost chimpanzee authority (having conducted a 45-year study), told CBC‘s the fifth estate that chimps separated from their mothers develop psychological scars common to abused children.

In an LA Times article, Goodall says that Clyde from Any Which Way You Can fame was trained with mace and a newspaper-wrapped pipe. And…“…the orangutan was caught stealing doughnuts on the set, brought back to the training facility and beaten for 20 minutes with a 3 1/2-foot ax handle. He died soon after of a cerebral hemorrhage.” Tyler was the lovable chimp who spat at Kramer on Seinfeld, and Ripley was cast as an astronaut in the 2002 movie Race To Space. The retired show business duo (joined by Ruben and Jimmy Joe) escaped from their unlocked cage at Zoo Nebraska in 2005. Ripley returned; the others did not. Police were called, bullets hailed, and the three chimps were killed. Travis, another entertainment veteran (Old Navy and Coke), was shot dead in February 2009 after attacking his mother’s friend (chilling 911 call). Theories abounded (the victim’s new hairstyle, Lyme disease, Xanax), but Travis’ history in captivity was the proverbial elephant in the room. Ironically, Travis’ mom, Suzy, was killed in 2001 after fleeing her owners’ (who bred, rented, and sold primates) ranch in Missouri.

Primatologist Sarah Baeckler went undercover for 14 months (2002-2003) at Sid Yost’s Amazing Animal Actors (his chimps, Sable, Cody, and Angel, were in That 70’s Show) in California. She says: “The trainers use physical force to train the chimps and other animals as well, but they punch them, they kick them. They use weapons such as a sawed off broom handle that they called the ugly stick. They used them…to threaten the chimps but also to strike them. They throw rocks and locks and hard things at them; these are baby chimpanzees…. The events I witnessed horrified me. I am not exaggerating when I tell you I saw sickening acts of emotional, psychological, and physical abuse every single day on the job. You can’t create that level of control without abusing them.” Owing almost entirely to Baeckler’s evidence, Yost was ordered to retire his clients. Steve Martin, a 40-year veteran of animal training, counters: “You become the mother…. Cause it’s just like with children. Some people believe in never having any discipline and then some parents might think a swift smack on the butt might do this kid some good. So I mean who’s to say who’s right?”

Because they soon grow too big (200 lbs and up) and too strong (3x an average man) to control, their careers are short. Washed up at seven, they face further exploitation through old age. There are over 2,000 captive chimps in American and Canada. The lucky ones find refuge at a sanctuary (Save the Chimps). For most, though, roadside zoos and research facilities. When questioned as to the whereabouts of one of his former actors (Kirby) by the fifth estate, Steve Martin had no answer. In fact, a caged Kirby was found begging for food in an Arkansas roadside zoo. Chubs from Planet of the Apes was videotaped eating dog food and rotten produce at a similar operation in Texas. And they may be there for another four or five decades.

Jane Goodall recommends euthanasia for those that cannot be rescued. As the largest supplier of exotics in the field (and one of the few who still has chimps), Steve Martin has offered to sell his remaining stock to sanctuaries. Otherwise, his lawyer writes in a letter to potential buyers, he “…intends to commence the breeding to explore and exploit the new business opportunities.” Shame on Steve Martin. Shame on all the breeders, sellers, and buyers. Shame on producers, directors, and actors. And shame on us (myself included) for laughing at their precocious antics, never bothering to ask who they are, how they arrived on stage, and what that life entails. Shame on the whole dirty, rotten, corrupt industry.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.